Yes. All motors in the FEDS retrofit database meet current applicable EPAct and EISA efficiency standards that vary depending on parameters, such as motor horsepower, enclosure type, and speed.
No. FEDS infers parameters based on the most likely current condition of a building and its equipment. Inferences for an 1820 vintage building will reflect the typical improvements and upgrades that have occurred over time.
If the building is newer than the rated life of the equipment in question, then the remaining life is equal to the difference of rated life and building age. If the building is older than the equipment's rated life, FEDS assumes that on average, equipment will be halfway through their life (but users can override this assumption and specify actual equipment vintage). Rated lives vary by equipment technology. Some examples of rated lives used in FEDS are:
envelope components (windows, insulation, etc.) – 40 years
lights – typically 25 years (Although the cost of replacing lamps and ballasts is figured into the analysis based on specific replacement intervals and hours of operation)
boilers – 40 years
furnaces – 20 years
chillers – 20 years
package AC units – 15 years
heat pumps – Air Source/15 years, Ground-Coupled/20 years
motors – 15 years
hot water heaters – electric, 12 years; gas, 10 years; distributed heat pump, 12 years; central heat pump, 15 years
While FEDS models motor energy use, demand, and interactions with the HVAC system quite well, it is not a substitute for the MotorMaster+ software. MotorMaster+ contains extensive motor management and analysis capabilities that are found in no other software program. FEDS recommends general categories and performance levels of motors based on what is currently available, but does not specify particular manufacturers or special features. It is recommended that results of motor analyses from FEDS be used in MotorMaster+ to further refine and specify motor purchase requirements.
For example, the effect of the affinity laws on fan motors can have a significant impact in degrading the efficiency of an energy-efficient motor if it has less slip than the original motor. While it is true that many energy-efficient motors run faster than their standard efficiency counterparts, there are typically energy-efficient motors available with a full-load rpm equivalent to that of the motor it is replacing. FEDS does not account for the effect of speed on energy consumption in centrifugal loads, but assumes the user can find a motor with an equivalent slip as their current motor. MotorMaster+ is an invaluable tool to help users assess the impact of speed on energy consumption and finding the right motor for a given application.
FEDS contains a built-in database of building survey data and is able to infer a number of building parameters based on the small set of required inputs provided by the user. For example, FEDS uses information such as building type, location, floor area, and vintage to determine the most likely construction type and geometry. It uses similar information along with heating fuel type and cooling equipment, to determine the most likely heating technology and ventilation system parameters for a building. All inferences enable a user to model buildings without having intimate knowledge of the detailed engineering parameters. The resulting building prototype parameter values are statistically the most likely values based on the limited set of information provided. Of course, all inferred data may be easily overwritten by simply entering (locking) a value in the user interface screens.
inking two distinct building sets together allows greater flexibility in modeling complex building geometries or uses. Linked buildings are designed to model two buildings that share a common wall or are stacked on top of one another. Specifying that the buildings are linked directs FEDS to automatically (based on the geometry information for each building) determine the wall area (or roof/ceiling area) that is shared, and thus not exposed to exterior conditions. It essentially calculates the portion of each buildings shell that is an adiabatic surface (i.e., does not experience conductive heat transfer) and does not receive solar gains. It uses this information in load calculations to appropriately account for the impact of the buildings being connected. There are some rules, however, that must be satisfied in order to link building sets. First, both sets must contain the same number of buildings so that a direct one-to-one linking is achieved. Second, both sets must have the solar normalization turned off (calculate solar gains by facing direction). Also, FEDS currently does not model cantilevered buildings so for top/bottom linking, the N/S and E/W lengths of the top building must not be greater than the corresponding lengths of the bottom building.
FEDS draws upon a number of sources to determine inferable parameter values. Major sources include national building energy consumption surveys such as the Commercial Buildings Energy Consumption, Residential Energy Consumption Survey, large end-use studies such as the End-Use Load and Consumer Assessment Program, ASHRAE handbooks, building and equipment codes and standards, and manufacturers' data and extensive building audit and evaluation experience.
A locked value, in terms of FEDS inputs, is one that the user has entered for an inferable parameter. This indicates to the model that this is a user-entered value and should not be updated (inferred). Clicking on the lock symbol can also lock a currently inferred value. When a value is locked, the lock icon will appear as a latched or closed lock. To unlock a value, simply click the icon again, changing it to an open or unlatched lock. This value will now be inferred the next time inferences are run.
Prototype buildings in FEDS are modeled as basic rectangular blocks, with the actual geometry calculated based on the total floor area, number of floors, floor-to-floor height, and aspect ratio. However, additional geometries can be modeled by using the linked building approach or through the advanced geometry inputs, which allow modification to underlying parameters including window/wall/roof/floor areas and conditioned air volumes.
FEDS project costing algorithms account for any materials, taxes, and labor costs applicable to a given retrofit measure. Additionally, 15% contractor overhead, 10% design cost, and 6% site level supervisory, inspection and overhead factors are applied, along with any multipliers specified on the regional costs screen under the financial options. Note that many of the cost factors reflect real regional variation, including labor rates, materials cost multipliers, and sales tax rates—with differentiation driven by the specified zip code. Each of these parameters are also able to be modified by the user, if appropriate.
The non-annual maintenance cost is used by FEDS to account for costs recurring on a non-annual basis, such as incremental equipment replacements and replacing failed lamps and ballasts. For example, the present value of the non-annual maintenance cost for lighting represents the present value of the total cost (including materials and labor) to replace the burned-out lamps and ballasts of a particular lighting technology over the course of the study period (generally 25 years).
FEDS employs the same standard life-cycle costing methodology and algorithms as the building life-cycle costing computer program developed by the National Institute of Standards and Technology.
The utilization factor represents the percentage of time during a particular period that the motor is operating. The load factor indicates the typical operating output of the motor as a percentage of rated output. For example, a 10-horsepower motor driving a 6-horsepower load and operating 50% of the time would have a load factor of 60% and a combined utilization/load factor of 30%.
FEDS allows the user to specify this information separately for occupied and unoccupied hours, either constant over the year, or varying from month to month. FEDS uses these values to calculate the hours of operation, and hence the consumption, and demand implications of each motor record. FEDS also calculates the heat output of the motors and its impact on the HVAC system.
The advanced geometry inputs allow for more flexibility in modeling non-standard building geometries compared to the linked building approach. When accessing the advanced geometry inputs, the user may specify or alter a number of geometric parameters for each zone of the building to customize the resulting model. For example, the exterior wall areas and window areas can be specified for the north, east, south, and west sides of each zone. Additionally, roof, floor, footprint areas, exterior perimeter length, and conditioned air volume can be specified for each zone. These adjustments provide users with the ability to model a number of more complex geometries, such as individual parts of a strip mall complex or varying window fractions for different sides of a building, with greater accuracy than through other means. The option can be accessed via the button on the regular geometry inputs screen.
Many motors in use today are oversized for the load they are driving, and some are grossly oversized. In such situations, the motor is driving a load equal to only a fraction of its rated capacity, and if too low the operating efficiency of the motor may suffer. Most importantly, when it's time to replace the motor, purchasing a motor with far excess capacity for its load will cost much more than a properly sized motor. Why spend more than necessary for the same (or even worse) level of service? FEDS understands t many motors may be over- (or under-) sized and allows the user to specify the required capacity of a motor, if known. FEDS will use the required capacity in order to select a replacement motor of the proper size and base its performance and cost calculations accordingly.
Solar normalization is used when the orientation of a single building is unknown, does not align with N/S/E/W directions, or when there are multiple buildings of differing orientations in a building set. It can be used to avoid biasing the solar gains calculation by normalizing the exterior wall, window, and roof areas, such that the resultant loads are roughly the average of two buildings: one with an east/west orientation and one with a north/south orientation. FEDS can be set to "ignore facing directions" to use solar normalization.
The aspect ratio is used to define the geometric orientation of the buildings in a building set. It is a ratio of length to width and is calculated by dividing the typical north-facing length by the typical east-facing length.
The discount rate is the factor used to adjust (discount) future sums of money into the equivalent current year dollar amount. It can also be thought of as the interest rate or hurdle rate (i.e., the rate of return required by a company for it to undertake a project). FEDS uses the real discount rate, which has the effect of inflation removed. FEDS provides the current Federal real discount rate as the default, but the user may enter any discount rate appropriate for their projects. Energy service companies performing shared energy savings contracts typically require real rates of return in the neighborhood of 10 to 20%.
The global cost multiplier is an overall cost multiplier applied to the total project cost (including all materials, labor, taxes, overhead). It can be used to adjust all of the total project costs used in FEDS economic calculations. This could be used for such purposes as to account for special cost-impacting requirements of working at a facility with stringent security requirements or health and safety risks, or to assess the impact of varying costs on project economics.
On the bottom right of some input screens (windows, lighting, heating, cooling, hot water, and motors) is a check box labeled "replacement required". The purpose of this selection is to tell FEDS that this particular building component or technology must be replaced. Whether it has failed (for example, windows are broken, or the furnace has stopped working), or a replacement or upgrade is planned, checking this box will force a replacement to be evaluated and selected when the FEDS optimization analysis is run. If a replacement option is cost effective, FEDS will work as normal; however, if one is not, FEDS will still provide the recommendation even though it may not be otherwise cost effective. FEDS will still report the most cost-effective option and all of the standard details to help users make informed decisions. This option is also known as replace on failure economics.
FEDS project costs are based on industry averages and may not match the exact costs you will be charged. The end-use and technology multipliers are intended to enable the user to adjust for these discrepancies so that the costs used in the FEDS analyses are as close to actual as possible. The recommended approach would be to first enter any known cost data (such as, labor rates, tax rate, discount rate, etc.), and then run FEDS, generate reports, and see what types of projects are coming up. Compare the project costs to actual known costs or bids for similar projects of that type. If any of the technology costs are grossly high or low, adjust them appropriately with a technology multiplier. Rerun FEDS to see if the same technology is being selected, and make sure that the costs more closely represent what the anticipated cost to complete the project. Because of the complex nature of the FEDS cost data, this iterative multiplier approach is the best way for users to modify project costs.
Motor inference data and an extensive list of replacement motors (including performance and cost data) have been compiled from the MotorMaster+ software's extensive database of three-phase motors. MotorMaster+ was developed under the U.S. Department of Energy's Motor Challenge Program by the Washington State University Cooperative Extension Energy Program.